Amazon Associates PartnerTrusted
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. This helps support our site at no extra cost to you. Clicking on ingredient or equipment links will take you to amazon.com where you can purchase these items.
Homemade Uncrustable Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwiches
A step‑by‑step recreation of the iconic frozen Uncrustable sandwich. Soft, pillowy homemade sandwich bread is enriched with a water‑roux for extra moisture, paired with a smooth, lightly salted homemade peanut butter and a bright grape‑apple jelly. The result is a crust‑less, perfectly round sandwich that can be made ahead and frozen for quick lunches.
Shop all ingredients on Amazon in one click • Printable PDF with shopping checklist
Cost Breakdown
Critical Success Points
- • Make the water‑roux; it determines the softness of the bread
- • Knead the dough until smooth; under‑mixing yields a dense crumb
- • Bake to an internal temperature of 190°F; under‑baking leaves a gummy interior
- • Strain the apple‑juice mixture to achieve a clear jelly
- • Use the wrinkle test to confirm jelly set
- • Crimp the sandwich edges firmly to seal without crust
Safety Warnings
- • Handle hot roux and boiling jelly with care to avoid burns
- • Use oven mitts when removing hot bread from the oven
- • When using a food processor or blender, keep the lid securely locked
☕ 100% Free & Ad-Free Forever! Made by ADHD friends who got lost in recipe videos
We built this because we kept forgetting recipe steps. Help us keep it ad-free & support our caffeine addiction!
You Might Also Like
Similar recipes converted from YouTube cooking videos
